Need help with your business technology?

p: (415) 409-9557 e: adria@butyoureagirl.com

Why I WON’T Get A Nexus One And Extend My T-Mobile Contract

All day on Twitter, people have been talking about the newly released, Google phone.  It’s called the Nexus One and runs Google’s Open Source software called Android.  Not having an Android, I’ve watched from the sidelines as people bragged about how superior the Android OS was compared to the iPhone operating system.

Well, my time has come because T-mobile just confirmed I’m due for contract renewal February 20th, 2010!
Google Nexus One Android phone

Top 10 Reasons I Will Buy The Nexus One

  1. I support Open Source Software
  2. All my geeky friends have Android based phones
  3. I worship Google
  4. It has a 5 megapixel camera with flash
  5. I keep jailbreaking my iPhone to get the freedom the Nexus One already has
  6. It’s not the iPhone
  7. It has 290 hours of standy by time (almost 2 weeks)
  8. It’s probably secretly tied into Google Wave
  9. It has a removable battery (yes, I didn’t stutter)
  10. Did I mention it’s not an iPhone?

I enjoy technology because it empowers people.  One of the ways you achieve freedom is by choice.

Get Your Milk Direct From The Cow

Now, in an unprecedented move (Just like how George Lucas didn’t show opening credits in Star Wars), Google is selling this phone on their website.  I cannot even begin to say how important this is as a statement to Open Source and *cough* *cough*, the open market.  Cell phone companies are playing with us giving us crippled phones.

UPDATE: One of my commenters, vaunnorwood, said that I would have to pay $379 so I investigated. Turns out that T-mobile is only providing full or partial discounts based on where you are in your contract so even at the end of a 2 year agreement, you are only eligible for $250 off.

Customers up for a full discount get $250 off and customers eligible for a partial discount (1 year into contract?) get $150 off the $579 price tag when you buy it without a contract.

  • If you buy this phone outright with no contract, you will pay $529 which is almost as much as the 16GB iPhone 3GS.
  • If you’re eligible for a partial discount (1 year into a 2 year contract?) you’re eligible for a $150 discount and will pay $429
  • If you are out of contract after 2 years, you can receive a $250 discount and pay $329
  • If activate a new line, with a 2 year contract AND select the “Even More” plan (which looks ridiculously expensive) you pay $179.

Google Nexus One Purchase choices

Am I Eligible For The Discounted Nexus One?

That said, T-mobile is the first provider available for this phone.  End of today, I called T-mobile to see if I was eligible.  I read off my phone number and provided the last four digits of my social security number to the rep.  I held my breath.

Google Nexus One Checking availability

The phone I got from T-mobile was a Samsung Beat but while waiting I couldn’t remember when I bought it!  Of course, I’ve been using the iPhone with my T-mobile sim card ever since OhDoctah sent me his old iPhone and then switched it to my new iPhone I won this year at Blogging While Brown.

Ok, back to the suspenseful waiting period.

The rep came back and said yes!  I had purchased my phone in March 2008 so I would be eligible in Feburary 2010!  Of course, I immediately tweeted this out:
Woot!  I'm getting a Nexus One!

T-mobile Treats Me Like A Princess

I’m happy with T-mobile’s service, coverage and customer service.  They are always nice to me when I call and have even comp’d me with extra minutes when I was about to go over.

In 2009, I was offered the T-mobile “Loyalty” plan which is $50/month for unlimited national calling.  This not only saved me $20 each month, I no longer had to worry about support calls to vendors eating up my minutes.
Is this for real?  Tmobile unlimited for $49.99 month?
It was also super easy to get my iPhone connected to T-mobile’s data plan.

Of the one problem I had with them trying to charge me for a free phone, The Consumerist website helped me get that silly $20 fee waived.

Latest and the Greatest

I will watch the CES buzz this year about all the new gadgets but I won’t be hopping on most because it leads to consumption without appreciation.  Gina Trapani had an interesting item over at her site that lined to Last Year’s Model, a site dedicated to raising awareness of our “disposable” views on electronics.  You’ll find the badge on my site as well.  I’ve seen it too many times where someone doesn’t even know how to use something and they’re upgrading to the next version.  One day, we will have less resources and our demands will outweigh them.  I like to feel I’m doing my part by taking care of my electronics so they have a long live and only upgrading when I’ve determined there is an essential functionality I need.  That’s the treehugger in me.
I'm Sticking With Last Year's Model

  • Are you going to get a Nexus One?
  • If you already have an Android based device, what would make you upgrade?
  • Are you sick of Apple controlling what goes on the iPhone?
Blog Widget by LinkWithin
  • http://twitter.com/s0l_uk Bill C

    Oh! lucky you!! I gotta wait at least another 6 months before I can think of getting a new phone! (Or buy it sim free)

  • JamesAla

    ” Are you sick of Apple controlling what goes on the iPhone?” No it is their device they get to call the shots. Don't like the way they run their shop, don't buy their product.

    “Are you going to get a Nexus One?” If offers a painless way to manage Podcast down-loads, maybe. It all depends if Apple insists on continuing their relationship with AT&T. The DSL service from Ma Bell works for me but the Cell Service consistently rates at the bottom of Consumer Union's test scores. A jail-broken iPhone that uses the T mobile network is a better fit for me as I am absolutely tethered to my iPod classic. A nexus one that does the podcast drill and rides on verizon's network and does not cost and arm an leg on cell charges would bring me over to the dark side.

  • http://twitter.com/tweetmeblack tweetmeblack.com

    My Tmo contract is up as well… I've been waiting 2 mos for this Nexus One stuff to decide if I should get it…. I'm still on the fence cause I love a physical keyboard!

    I know that is a bit old lady of me but I'm wary of all that touchscreen newfangledness… LOL Thanks for posting this Adria… I was going to ask you about it!

  • http://twitter.com/silentbutsmart SILENTBUTSMART

    I will definitely get one now thanks to your awesome straightforward no frills review. AT&T disappointed me (they wouldn't do a free upgrade to the 9700 and the plms of the network just was a turnoff for me in regard to considering an iPhone bec I wasn't with them long enough) and I was like are u serious?

    I should have not never left T-mobile but I was mad (but they could have told me to wait bec they was dropping all these good phones recently) smh and I did have an iPhone but I got tired of jailbreaking the phone! lol

    So I will get the Nexus One at the beginning of February.

    I am on the fence in regard to the iTablet (need some key info on it before making a purchase!)

  • vaunnorwood

    I'm sorry, you will not be eligible for the the $179 price, that is only for new customers with new phone numbers. Tmobile customers that are out of contract pay $379 plus you still have to sign a new 2 year contract.

  • http://butyoureagirl.com adriarichards

    Just verified you're right about this. Customers up for a full discount get
    $250 off and customers eligible for a partial discount (1 year into
    contract?) get $150 off the $579 price tag when you buy it without a
    contract.

    Sheesh!!!

  • http://www.runningwithoutcondition.com André Sanders

    Adria: I'm confused, that 179.00 price comes with the Tmobile 500 minutes plan. From what I've read, when you get the subsidized phone price, you HAVE to switch to the Tmobile 500 rate plan. In other words, you can't keep your 49.99 unlimited loyalty plan (which is the same one I'm on) AND have the subsidized price of 179.00; you would have to pay the full price of the unlocked phone. Now, with that being said, were you told something different?

  • http://www.runningwithoutcondition.com André Sanders

    I just called tmobile and here is basically what I was told:

    If you choose to have the subsidized pricing, you HAVE to switch to the tmobile 500 minutes plan. You can't keep your loyalty price plan. However, after staying on the 500 minutes plan for one month (which was the stupid deal that Tmobile worked out with Google) you can switch to a different plan and here is how your choices work:
    1. you can switch to any of the even more plans, but the equivalent one to the Loyalty plan would be the Even More Unlimited.

    or

    2. You can switch to the Even More PLUS plans, but in this case you HAVE to pay the $35.00 transfer fee to be on this “no contract” plan. You will continue with the Nexus One on the 2-year contract you agreed, but after that, you will move on with being on a “no contract required” plan, but have to pay full price (meaning, unsubsidized) for any future phones you buy through tmobile.

    Personally, I think this is ridiculous. I have literally, jump through a bunch of hoops, just to get back to an unlimited talk plan with this phone, while my cost of getting the phone keeps rising. For the life of me, I can not understand why Google would have done everything else so right with this phone and yet, screw it up hand-in-hand with Tmobile so badly with choosing a service plan. I had hoped to get this phone myself and am still considering it, but I am going to have to consider my “plan” of attack now… and BTW this does not even consider adding the price for the internet plan…

  • http://butyoureagirl.com adriarichards

    Andre,

    Thanks for looking into it! Now that is just crazy! When she was
    explaining the “Even More” plan (It really should be “Even Less”), I was
    just baffled why I would not want to keep paying $50 for unlimited national
    calling. Why would I switch to a more expensive plan that would give me
    less minutes?

    Now you're saying that if you did switch to get the subsidized rate, there
    is a “hot mess” you need to wade through and even when you're done, you
    won't be back to where you started?

    Did you inquire about the data plans? I wasn't clear if data was included
    but figured it was extra.

    There is no WAY I am going to pay $100+ per month for unlimited national
    calling

  • http://www.runningwithoutcondition.com André Sanders

    Adria:

    Here's the thing, you can continue on the 50 unlimited in two ways:
    1. Either pay for the unsubsidized plan and you can keep your loyalty
    plan that you and I have now
    2. Get the subsidized phone, stick with the 500 minute plan that they
    require for ONE month and then call tmobile and ask to switch over to
    their 49.99 Even More Plus (which is the plan for unsubsidized
    phones). If you do this, you have to pay an additional 35.00 fee to
    transfer to the Even More Plus option. Then after you complete the 2-
    year agreement that you already had with the subsidized nexus one, any
    future phone upgrades through tmobile will be at full, unsubsidized
    prices.

    So your second part was a bit incorrect, the “hot mess” is what you
    just read above. After that you'd be back to your unlimited plan
    choosing one of the paths noted above.

    I did inquire about the data plans and yes, what I noted originally
    and re-stated above, does not include the data plan option. With
    regards to that, you would have to add that on, depending on what plan
    you're on, it would be (I believe) an additional 30.00 or 34.99 price.
    But I believe that is across the board.

    I really want a new phone and preferably a high end phone. I like the
    iphone, but will not and can not tolerate AT&T at all. I also don't
    want to get into the “jailbreaking” issue. A friend did note something
    interesting if I am willing to pay the 529 price for the Nexus One,
    why not just buy the OEM version of the iphone 3gs which DOES support
    the 3G band that Tmobile uses. That is an interesting point and it's
    still cheaper by 29 bucks then the Nexus One. I lean towards android
    because I like the direction it is heading, but so many half ass
    situations… it really just sucks to have to keep playing this game.

  • http://butyoureagirl.com adriarichards

    Andre,

    Thanks for looking into the details. I wonder if I could keep my existing
    data plan which is priced at $19.99 vs $29.99

    It is a hot mess because I should not have to call up my cell phone provider
    and switch my plan twice and then agree that I won't get ANYMORE subsidies.

    I hope one of the petitions to T-mobile and Google makes them rethink this
    maze.

  • md20737

    Wow this is the first time I have ever heard such good talk about Tmobile. I always hear complaining. This new Nexus sounds great. I hope you enjoy it. My upgrade is coming soon as well!!

  • joshcaza

    My contract is up Feb. 22nd. I have a G1, and do love the iphone, but I will also be going to the Nexus One. I love being able to run custom ROMs, and, who doesn't love voice navigation on your phone? Good write up!

  • joshcaza

    My contract is up Feb. 22nd. I have a G1, and do love the iphone, but I will also be going to the Nexus One. I love being able to run custom ROMs, and, who doesn't love voice navigation on your phone? Good write up!